Argentine Peso Dives After Populist Peronists Gain Edge in Vote
|08/12/2019 | 05:22 pm|
By Ryan Dube and Jeffrey T. Lewis
Argentina's currency and stocks plunged amid investor concerns about the possible return to power of the country's populist Peronist movement, which advocates greater state control of the economy and opposes a landmark trade deal with the European Union.
The peso initially weakened more than 30% against the dollar after pro-business President Mauricio Macri was dealt a resounding defeat in a primary election Sunday against Alberto Fernández, a leftist whose vice-presidential running mate is former President Cristina Kirchner, a firebrand nationalist. The peso later recovered some ground.
Argentina's central bank stepped into currency markets Monday, auctioning off $50 million to try to support the peso. The bank's benchmark interest rate jumped to 74%, from 63.7% on Friday, according to local reports.
The Merval index in Buenos Aires closed 38% lower on Monday after jumping 7.7% Friday on expectations that Mr. Macri would come in a close second place in Sunday's primary, a mandatory vote that determines which parties will be able to run candidates in the October election.
Mr. Macri received 32% support versus 48% for Mr. Fernández, a far bigger margin than expected, setting up the opposition for a possible first-round victory against the incumbent in October's general election. The negative economic impact of the vote in Argentina creates further obstacles for Mr. Macri to hold on to power, analysts said.
"This is insurmountable; they are not going to recover from this," said Dardo Gasparré, an economist and political columnist who writes on Argentina. "The new government is going to be Peronist."
Voters cast a single ballot in a nationwide primary with candidates from all parties. Candidates that receive more than 1.5% support are eligible to run in the presidential election in October. As parties have already picked their candidate, the primary provides a strong indication of voter preference.
Mr. Macri told reporters on Monday that he won't make changes to his cabinet as a result of the primary, and blamed his performance in the election on the country's poor economy. He said the economy is now poised to return to growth, and the reaction of financial markets Monday showed that they don't trust his adversaries' policies.
"Today we're poorer than we were before the primary elections" because of the market reactions, he said. "The biggest problem Argentines have today is that the alternative has no credibility."
Mr. Macri declined to announce any measures intended to boost economic growth, saying his government is still studying options, and pledged to turn the election result around in time for the October vote.
In Buenos Aires, Argentines hurting from an economic recession and a surge in prices were bracing for the impact of the market turmoil. A weaker peso often fuels inflation in Latin America's third-biggest economy, currently at 56%, one of the world's highest rates.
"I'm afraid that everything is going to be more expensive," said restaurateur Domingo Gomez, who wants Mr. Macri to resign. "Don't they understand that the people don't want them anymore?"
Mr. Macri told reporters late Sunday that dealing with this week's volatility would be "the responsibility of everyone, especially those who received the most support today."
In a radio interview Monday, Mr. Fernández blamed the turmoil on Mr. Macri's government, which has taken on billions of dollars in foreign debt since taking office in late 2015 on a wave of optimism in Wall Street.
"The markets react badly when they realize they were ripped off," Mr. Fernández told Radio 10. "We are living in a fictitious economy...and the government isn't responding."
Still, Mr. Fernández tried to ease market concerns, seeking to reassure jittery Argentines that his administration would be responsible stewards of the economy. "We were never crazy governing," said Mr. Fernández, a former cabinet chief who is viewed as more moderate than his running mate. "We always resolved the problems that others created."
If elected, Mr. Fernández could unravel many of Mr. Macri's policies, raising doubts about the future of a trade deal between Argentina and three other South American countries with the European Union. He has voiced his opposition to the pact, though didn't address it this week.
The deal clinched in June would create a trade bloc of nearly 800 million people, representing a quarter of the world's economy. Though Brazil has the biggest economy in the South American Mercosur customs union that made the pact, it was Mr. Macri who was the most prominent Latin American proponent.
Mr. Macri's likely loss in October "is very negative" for the trade pact, said Benjamin Gedan, an Argentina expert at the Wilson Center, a Washington, D.C., policy group. "The process of even obtaining approvals within the EU would have depended strongly on Macri's diplomacy."
The deal needs approval Mercosur member countries Argentina, Brazil, Uruguay and Paraguay, and in Europe, where environmental advocates have raised concerns and farmers worry about competing with the industrialized farming of Brazil and Argentina.
"Classic protectionist fears are resurfacing in South America," said John Clancy, a former EU trade spokesman now with FTI Consulting, a business-advisory firm. "And there are similar aspects in Europe -- that's why it becomes such a difficult deal to see through."
In Brazil, some analysts feared the return of protectionist policies could undercut relations Mercosur.
Mr. Macri's standing with voters suffered severely after an economic crisis that began last year amid concerns about the country's ability to pay its debts. The peso lost half its value against the dollar over about five months, while inflation shot up and joblessness rose. Some economic indicators are starting to show small improvements, but gross domestic product dropped 5.8% in the first quarter from a year earlier, and unemployment is still above 10%. Last year, the government received a $57 billion bailout from the International Monetary Fund, the fund's largest ever, to cope with a currency crisis.
On Monday, Ricardo Dabras, a painter in Buenos Aires, couldn't buy material in a hardware store that refused to sell products due to the peso's collapse. "This is crazy," he said. "I don't know what I'm going to do."
Robert Scott III, an economist at Monmouth University who specializes on Latin America, said Mr. Macri's cuts to utility subsidies would likely be reversed in a Fernández administration. He said a new government might also be quick to implement currency controls that suffocate exporters.
Many Argentines fear a return of those policies that were implemented by Mrs. Kirchner and blamed by most economists for the mess that Mr. Macri inherited. During her eight years in power, Mrs. Kirchner ran large budget deficits and nationalized businesses. Her administration, which ended in 2015, was also mired in corruption allegations. Mrs. Kirchner is currently facing trial for graft, which she denies.
Mariela Beltran, a 38-year-old shopkeeper in Buenos Aires, said she was worried about the return of Mrs. Kirchner.
"I'm going to vote for Macri because I don't see an alternative" she said. "If the Peronists return, the past returns, the corruption."
, Paulo Trevisani, Ira Iosebashvili and Emre Peker contributed to this article.
Write to Ryan Dube at email@example.com and Jeffrey T. Lewis at firstname.lastname@example.org